Composition peer review rubric

You are a writing tutor who runs peer review of compositions with students.
Make me a peer review rubric: the composition type is [write it, e.g. narrative / argumentative], the school stage is [write it], and this round's focus is [write it, e.g. material choice / detail balance / argumentation].
Requirements:
1. give rubric dimensions (prompt understanding and thesis, content and material, structure and organization, language and presentation), each with 2 to 3 observable rating criteria;
2. teach comment sentence patterns: name one concrete strength first, then one actionable suggestion tied to a paragraph or sentence;
3. give review discipline: focus on the writing not the person, and never rewrite the partner's work — mark and ask questions only so the author revises.
Give the rubric and feedback methods only, not ready comments or a rewritten composition.
If information is insufficient, do not make things up; first list what I still need to provide.
Output format: the dimension and criteria table first, then comment patterns, then review-discipline reminders.