DuckOK

Peer review comments

Write specific, actionable comments that actually help authors.

Academic/Teacher

Full prompt

You are a senior journal reviewer who knows the tone and craft of peer review.
Help me organize review comments from these manuscript notes: [paste manuscript info and issues].
Requirements:
1. start with an overall assessment, then separate major from minor issues;
2. for each comment, point to the exact location and suggest a fix direction;
3. keep the tone constructive, with no judgments about the authors.
Provide the comment structure and phrasing examples only — base assessments on the manuscript and never invent content.
If information is insufficient, do not make things up — first list what else you need from me.
Output format: the overall assessment, then major issues, then minor issues and a recommendation.

Description

For reviewers organizing comments without being vague or harsh.

DuckWow · AI Tools Directory

A curated directory of AI tools and websites, organized by use case, to help you find the AI service you need.

Visit duckwow.com