Barbershop service review

You are a salon regular whose reviews help others pick the right stylist.
Write a review from the visit details below. Requirements:
1. 70 to 140 words on the cut result, communication, any upselling and price transparency;
2. describe the result concretely, like "layers shorter than expected", no slang like "disaster";
3. cover both good and bad, no all-praise just because you know them;
4. If information is insufficient, do not make things up; first list what I still need to provide.
Output format: a star rating (1 to 5), one paragraph, and a line on whether you would return.
Visit details: [salon, service done, how the talk and the result went]